{
  "schema": "COM010_LAB_CASES_v1",
  "cases": [
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "claim source trace + DOM label trace + intent trace + duplication trace",
      "score_or_state": "PASS",
      "severity": "NONE",
      "blocking_flag": false,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "PASS",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": false,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "baseline_pass"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "CLAIM-PERF has no current source",
      "score_or_state": "FAIL",
      "severity": "CRITICAL",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "FAIL_CLAIM_SUPPORT",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "FAIL",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": true,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "unsupported_claim"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "form label not associated with control",
      "score_or_state": "FAIL",
      "severity": "CRITICAL",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "FAIL",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "FAIL_ACCESSIBILITY",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": true,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "accessibility_critical"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "",
      "score_or_state": "UNKNOWN",
      "severity": "UNKNOWN",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "HOLD_MISSING_EVIDENCE",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": false,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "missing_evidence"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "8",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "PASS evidence belongs to version 7; current artifact is version 8",
      "score_or_state": "STALE",
      "severity": "MAJOR",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "HOLD_STALE_ARTIFACT",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": false,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "stale_artifact"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "critical accessibility failure was relabeled advisory",
      "score_or_state": "PASS",
      "severity": "ADVISORY",
      "blocking_flag": false,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "PASS",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "FAIL_SEVERITY_POLICY",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": true,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "severity_downgrade"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "high duplication; audience/purpose is distinct and documented",
      "score_or_state": "REVISE",
      "severity": "MAJOR",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "PASS",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "FAIL",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "REVISE_DUPLICATION",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": false,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "duplication_clear_intent"
    },
    {
      "qa_run_id": "QA-LAB-1",
      "artifact_id": "PAGE-42",
      "artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewed_artifact_version": "7",
      "reviewer": "reviewer-lab",
      "dimension_id": "aggregate_decision",
      "dimension_type": "COMPOSITE_VIEW",
      "criticality": "CRITICAL",
      "criterion": "All critical dimensions evidentially closed",
      "observable_evidence": "substantial duplication and audience intent unresolved",
      "score_or_state": "HOLD",
      "severity": "MAJOR",
      "blocking_flag": true,
      "claim_refs": [
        "COM-010-K1",
        "COM-010-K2",
        "COM-010-K3",
        "COM-010-K4"
      ],
      "accessibility_check": "PASS",
      "intent_fit_check": "UNKNOWN",
      "helpfulness_check": "PASS",
      "duplication_check": "FAIL",
      "conversion_check": "PASS",
      "repair_action": "none",
      "retest_result": "PASS",
      "final_state": "HOLD_INTENT_DUPLICATION",
      "evidence_ref": "EVID-LAB-BASE",
      "claim_support_check": "PASS",
      "artifact_version_current": true,
      "critical_failure_present": false,
      "advisory_defect_open": false,
      "id": "transfer_duplicate_ambiguous_intent"
    }
  ]
}