{
  "schema": "MAKNOW_COM006_LAB_FIXTURES_v1",
  "cases": [
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "baseline_released"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": null,
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "verify_model_identity_missing"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v2",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "edit_from_wrong_artifact"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "OBJECT"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "verifier_objection_overwritten"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": true,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 0,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-E",
          "model_id": "model-E2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "fallback_drops_caveats"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PENDING",
          "approval_state": "PENDING"
        }
      ],
      "id": "models_agree_no_human_approval"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": "EV-X",
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": null,
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "stage_policy_missing"
    },
    {
      "editorial_run_id": "RUN-X",
      "evidence_ref": null,
      "human_anchor_id": "H-9",
      "verified_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
      "fallback_used": false,
      "source_linked_caveats_before": 2,
      "source_linked_caveats_after": 2,
      "verifier_objection_disposition": null,
      "stages": [
        {
          "role": "RESEARCH",
          "input_artifact_id": "brief-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-A",
          "model_id": "model-A1",
          "policy_version": "POL-RES-v3",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-0",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "DRAFT",
          "input_artifact_id": "research-v1",
          "output_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "model_provider": "provider-B",
          "model_id": "model-B2",
          "policy_version": "POL-DRAFT-v5",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "N/A"
        },
        {
          "role": "VERIFY",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "verify-v1",
          "model_provider": "provider-C",
          "model_id": "model-C4",
          "policy_version": "POL-VERIFY-v6",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "role": "EDIT",
          "input_artifact_id": "draft-v3",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "provider-D",
          "model_id": "model-D1",
          "policy_version": "POL-EDIT-v4",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "VERIFY_PASS_PRESERVED"
        },
        {
          "role": "APPROVE",
          "input_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "output_artifact_id": "final-v4",
          "model_provider": "HUMAN",
          "model_id": "N/A",
          "policy_version": "POL-APP-v2",
          "source_bundle_ref": "SRC-17",
          "claim_set_ref": "CLAIMS-7",
          "review_result": "APPROVED",
          "approval_state": "APPROVED"
        }
      ],
      "id": "missing_evidence_ref"
    }
  ]
}