{
  "lesson_id": "COM-004",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "baseline_verified",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "device_profile_changed_unrecorded",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "desktop",
      "context_recorded": false,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "score_up_critical_unresolved",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "CRITICAL",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": true,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 98,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "tool_upgrade_check_disappears",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "13.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": false,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "manual_dispute_without_reviewer",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "MANUAL",
      "false_positive_state": "FALSE_POSITIVE",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "missing_raw_evidence",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "partial_template_fix",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "12.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "largest-contentful-paint",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "HIGH",
      "automated_or_manual": "AUTOMATED",
      "false_positive_state": "NO",
      "reviewer_identity": null,
      "manual_review_evidence": null,
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template",
        "product-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": false
    },
    {
      "id": "transfer_diagnostic_change_partial_and_disputed",
      "audit_run_id": "WA-RUN-1",
      "target_url": "https://example.test/pricing",
      "canonical_page_id": "PAGE-PRICING",
      "crawl_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "tool_name": "Lighthouse",
      "tool_version": "13.x-recorded",
      "device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "rerun_device_profile": "mobile-simulated",
      "context_recorded": true,
      "audit_category": "Performance",
      "check_id": "new-performance-insight",
      "check_present_in_rerun": true,
      "raw_result_ref": "RAW-1",
      "metric_name": "LCP",
      "metric_value": 3.4,
      "threshold_source": "LH-reference",
      "finding_id": "F-001",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "confidence": "MEDIUM",
      "automated_or_manual": "MANUAL",
      "false_positive_state": "DISPUTED",
      "reviewer_identity": "reviewer-7",
      "manual_review_evidence": "REV-EV-7",
      "owner": "frontend",
      "remediation_ref": "FIX-1",
      "rerun_ref": "RUN-2",
      "critical_unresolved": false,
      "aggregate_score_before": 72,
      "aggregate_score_after": 91,
      "fix_scope": [
        "pricing-template"
      ],
      "expected_scope": [
        "pricing-template",
        "product-template"
      ],
      "evidence_ref": [
        "EV-1"
      ],
      "verification_claim": "VERIFIED",
      "transfer_mode": true
    }
  ]
}